Need an opinion: sweat proof liquid eyeliner.

topic posted Fri, August 21, 2009 - 7:44 PM by  phaedra
Share/Save/Bookmark
Advertisement
What liquid eyeliner do you think is the best when you are performing outdoors on a hot summer day? My first guess would be MAC Liquidlast, but I don't like the brush applicator. I like a felt tip applicator better. So I thought I would throw this out to all of you. Is there anything that you swear by?
posted by:
phaedra
Advertisement
Advertisement
  • Re: Need an opinion: sweat proof liquid eyeliner.

    Fri, August 21, 2009 - 7:46 PM
    None. I'd recommend a creme eyeliner, like L'Oreal HIP or MAC Fluidline. Creme has more staying power through the sweat than liquid ever will.
    • Re: Need an opinion: sweat proof liquid eyeliner.

      Fri, August 21, 2009 - 7:51 PM
      I'll give you that but I hate the way cream applies... I've tried them. Maybe it's just a learning curve or I'm using the wrong brush. Maybe I need a better cream liner. The ones I have are the gel ones. I'm addicted to my felt tip applicator. Maybe i should try to find one of those for my creme liners... hmmmm... It's got me thinking! Thanks for the input!
      • Re: Need an opinion: sweat proof liquid eyeliner.

        Sat, August 22, 2009 - 6:16 AM
        I understand, but you're right, practice & time does make a difference. How long did it take you to get this comfortable with the liquid liner? Were as stealthy as you are now when you first bought/tried it? :)

        I find that for creme liners, the brush does make the difference. I can't stand the ones that come with the HIP liners, for instance. I went to the art store & bought a small, angled brush like this: www.reuels.com/reuels/med...s80349L.jpg ...and I mean *tiny*. I find that I can get the control from that like you can with the liquid felt-tip liner. But since you're comfortable with the felt liner, you might try a brush that mimics that, like this one: www.goodcharacters.com/images...2-1.jpg

        Also, the more you pay for it, the better the quality. I like the HIP ones in general, but the fluidity of the MAC one is on a whole other level -- and also may make it easier to apply. Ben Nye also has creme liners (their "Creme Foundations" & "Creme Colors" on page 8 & 9: www.bennye.com/image/2007...Catalog.pdf ) & their quality is outstanding as well.
  • Re: Need an opinion: sweat proof liquid eyeliner.

    Wed, September 9, 2009 - 10:10 PM
    I absolutely ADORE Body Shop's liquid liner. I took a chance on it, and it hasn't let me down, not ever! It's a bit pricey, about 20.00, but it lasts forever. It's ultra black, goes on smooth, doesn't dry to quickly, never flakes and won't come off until you take the remover to it!
    Trust me, it's the best eyeliner ever. ;)
    • Re: Need an opinion: sweat proof liquid eyeliner.

      Thu, September 10, 2009 - 6:29 AM
      Creams- and practice- I wasn't sold on it to start either but practice and a good brush like Bellatrix said.

      I'm also finding I have good luck w/ combinations of pencils and shadows with any sort of cream/liquid liner. I use tons of product to really mash it into the eyelash line (Yeah I am the person that blows a ton of charcoal eyeshadow and black pencil liners then washes my face to make ABSOLUTELY sure its the racooon liner effect- then reapply all make up after fash washing lol)

      I play w/ it a lot and wear it to the gym- I try to overlap as many products to see what works and what doesn't... so don't be afraid to mix and match... (mascara- I always do a pumping fat brush + one of those weird new brushes gets length defintion AND the full fat coverage)

Recent topics in "Makeup and Hair for Dancers"

Topic Author Replies Last Post
How do I… DuckAmuck 19 Today, 11:57 AM
I just love my henna hair Sabine 16 Today, 9:41 AM
Best makeup/hair/shopping tutorial I've ever used....in my opi... Shaell 3 Yesterday, 12:58 PM
mineral eyeshadows? Elle 20 December 30, 2009